PRs over $25,000 require dual approval (Manager + Finance). Emergency PRs route directly to CEO Michael Levine.
P2Vendor Comparison MatrixPrice / Lead Time / Quality / MOQ / Terms
Barrel Cheddar 40 lb — Vendor Comparison for Q3 2026
Criteria
Bongards
Perham, MN
Preferred
Tillamook
Tillamook, OR
Great Lakes
Adams, WI
Price / lb
$2.18
CME + moisture premium
$2.34
Fixed quarterly
$2.26
CME + flat premium
Lead Time
5 days
8 days
6 days
Quality Score
96/100
92/100
88/100
Min Order Qty
20 blocks
40 blocks
30 blocks
Payment Terms
Net 30
Net 15
Net 30
Food Safety Cert
SQF Level 3
SQF Level 3
SQF Level 2
Recommendation
PREFERRED
Best price + quality + terms
BACKUP
Premium brand positioning
ALTERNATE
Regional supply option
Matrix updated quarterly. Quality scores based on incoming inspections (last 12 months). Price reflects CME trailing week + 35% moisture premium for Bongards.
P3RFQ TemplateRequest for Quote / Product Specs / Delivery Schedule
GFS
Global Food Solutions, Inc.
131 Heartland Blvd, Edgewood, NY 11717
REQUEST FOR QUOTE
RFQ-2026-0089
Date Issued:May 17, 2026
Response Due:May 24, 2026
Contact:Michael Levine, CEO
Email:procurement@GlobalFoodSolutions.co
Dear Vendor,
Global Food Solutions, Inc. invites you to submit a quotation for the following products. Please provide pricing, lead times, and terms per the specifications below.
Government spec, 5 lb loaves, 6 per case, shelf-stable
200 cases
6/5 lb
3
Shredded Mozzarella
LMPS, 4/5 lb bags per case, anti-cake agent, frozen acceptable
120 cases
4/5 lb
Delivery Requirements
Ship-To: 131 Heartland Blvd, Edgewood, NY 11717 Frequency: Weekly deliveries (Monday or Tuesday) Temperature: Refrigerated (34-40 F), reefer truck with temp logger Contract Period: July 1, 2026 – June 30, 2027 COA Required: Certificate of Analysis with each shipment
Please return your completed quote by May 24, 2026. We look forward to your response.
Michael Levine, CEO
Global Food Solutions, Inc.
RFQ template stored in NetSuite as form GFS-RFQ-001. Auto-populates vendor contact and product specs from item master.
New Vendor Evaluation — Weighted Scoring (100 Points Max)
Vendor Evaluation Scorecard
Form GFS-VE-001 · Rev. 05/2026
Vendor: Great Lakes Cheese
Evaluator: Michael Levine
#
Evaluation Criteria
Weight
Score (1-10)
Weighted Score
Notes
1
Product Quality & Consistency
15%
8
12.0
Good consistency, minor moisture variance noted
2
Pricing Competitiveness
15%
7
10.5
CME + flat premium, slightly above Bongards
3
On-Time Delivery Performance
12%
8
9.6
92% OTD over last 6 months
4
Food Safety Certification (SQF/BRC)
12%
7
8.4
SQF Level 2 (Level 3 preferred)
5
Financial Stability
10%
9
9.0
D&B rating: strong. Public company.
6
Communication & Responsiveness
8%
7
5.6
Avg RFQ response: 2.4 days (target: <2)
7
Capacity & Scalability
8%
9
7.2
Multiple plants, surge capacity available
8
Regulatory Compliance (USDA/FDA)
8%
9
7.2
USDA inspected, FDA registered, current
9
Payment Terms & Flexibility
6%
8
4.8
Net 30, willing to negotiate volume terms
10
Geographic Proximity / Logistics
6%
6
3.6
Adams, WI — 6-day transit to Edgewood
Total Weighted Score:
77.9 / 100
Approved
✓ 80+ = Preferred
● 65-79 = Approved
⚠ 50-64 = Conditional
✗ <50 = Rejected
Vendor evaluations stored in NetSuite custom record (GFS-VE). Re-evaluated annually or upon quality incident. Conditional vendors require corrective action plan within 30 days.
Incomplete onboarding blocks PO creation. All vendor documents stored in NetSuite file cabinet under vendor record. Annual re-certification of insurance and food safety docs required.
USDA Grade A barrel cheddar cheese, 500 lb barrels, minimum 35% moisture content, pasteurized, rBST-free. Volume: approximately 80 barrels per month for Northeast distribution.
2. Justification for Sole Source
Bongards Creameries is the only supplier that meets all of the following requirements simultaneously: (a) CME trailing-week pricing with 35% moisture premium bracket, (b) minimum order quantity of 20 blocks (lowest in market), (c) 5-day lead time to Edgewood, NY, (d) SQF Level 3 certification, and (e) Net 30 payment terms. Alternate suppliers Tillamook and Great Lakes were evaluated (see Vendor Comparison Matrix P2) but do not match on all five criteria.
3. Market Research Conducted
Three vendors were evaluated in Q1 2026. RFQ-2026-0089 was issued to Bongards, Tillamook, and Great Lakes Cheese. Detailed comparison documented in the Vendor Comparison Matrix (Section P2 of this design system).
4. Impact if Not Approved
Switching vendors would increase per-unit cost by $0.08-$0.16/lb ($38,400-$76,800 annually), extend lead times by 1-3 days, and require requalification with USDA programs. Customer contracts tied to CME+premium pricing would require renegotiation.
Requestor Signature
Michael Levine, CEO — 05/18/2026
Finance Approval
Required for all SSJ > $100,000
Sole source justifications required for any vendor receiving >$50,000 annually without competitive bidding. SSJs reviewed annually. Re-justification required if contract value increases >20%.
P11Approved Vendor List (AVL)Active Vendors / Category / Status / Certification / Review Date
Active Approved Vendors — Dairy & Protein Category
Vendor
Category
Location
Status
Food Safety
Score
Payment Terms
Next Review
Bongards Creameries
Cheese
Perham, MN
Preferred
SQF 3
93.6
Net 30
07/2026
Cal-Maine Foods
Eggs
Jackson, MS
Preferred
SQF 3
91.2
Net 15
08/2026
Grassland Dairy
Butter / Dairy
Greenwood, WI
Preferred
SQF 3
89.4
Net 30
09/2026
Leprino Foods
Mozzarella
Denver, CO
Approved
SQF 3
86.1
Net 30
10/2026
Great Lakes Cheese
Cheese
Adams, WI
Approved
SQF 2
77.9
Net 30
11/2026
Tillamook
Cheese
Tillamook, OR
Backup
SQF 3
82.3
Net 15
12/2026
Ardent Mills
Flour / Dry Goods
Denver, CO
Preferred
BRC A
90.8
Net 30
06/2026
Preferred Score 80+ / Primary supply
Approved Score 65-79 / Secondary option
Backup Qualified but not primary
Conditional Score 50-64 / Corrective action
AVL maintained in NetSuite. POs can only be created against vendors on the AVL. Vendor removal requires VP-level approval and 90-day transition plan.
← Back to Hub · GFS Design System v10.0 · Global Food Solutions, Inc. · Edgewood, NY